What makes Ayn Rand’s philosophy unique?
What makes Ayn Rand’s philosophy unique? Broadly speaking: the content
of her philosophy, Objectivism, and (connected to this) her conviction that
philosophy is crucially important.
Let’s first look at the latter.
To most modern philosophers philosophy is disconnected from life—nothing more
than an analysis of
language, or speculation about the unknowable, or an intellectual game—which is
why most people think philosophy is “just a lot of theory” (i.e., a waste of
time).
To Ayn Rand, by contrast, philosophy is a matter of life and death. On her
view, philosophy
studies the fundamental nature of existence, of man and of man’s relationship to
existence. “A philosophy,” such as Ayn Rand’s philosophy of Objectivism, is a
systematic, integrated view of existence—what used to be called “a philosophy of
life.” Far from being a useless game, philosophy, to Ayn Rand, is the
determining factor in an individual’s character and happiness and in every
aspect of a culture, including history, politics, education. Philosophic ideas
are important because one’s life is important, and philosophy is a practical
necessity for living. As Ayn Rand wrote:
In order to live, man must act; in order to act, he must make
choices; in order to make choices, he must define a code of values; in
order to define a code of values, he must know what he is and where he
is—i.e., he must know his own nature (including his means of knowledge)
and the nature of the universe in which he acts—i.e., he needs
metaphysics, epistemology, ethics, which means: philosophy. He cannot
escape from this need; his only alternative is whether the philosophy
guiding him is to be chosen by his mind or by chance.
Ayn Rand (“Philosophy and Sense of Life,” 1966)
Something else that makes Ayn Rand’s approach different: she holds that there
are answers to philosophic questions, even the most abstract questions, such as
“what is the relationship of concepts in our minds to the particular objects we
perceive?” Most philosophers think that answers are impossible—that at best we
can debate about whether one opinion is better or worse than some other—and
because of that, they see any claim to certainty as tantamount to dogmatism;
they fail to distinguish between answers derived from evidence and answers based
on religious faith.
Now here, briefly, is what is unique about Ayn Rand’s philosophy; it
is not just her approach to philosophy.
The nature of reality: Objectivism holds that things are what they are,
independent of anyone’s knowledge or wishes. Objectivism rejects both the view that reality is some supernatural realm
inaccessible to reason or that everyone has his own subjective reality.
Knowledge: Objectivism holds that reason is man’s only means of knowledge and
tool of survival and that certainty is attainable. Objectivism thus rejects both
the view that there is some non-rational means of knowledge (e.g., faith or
intuition), and the view that knowledge is impossible and truth is relative to
the individual or culture.
Human nature: Objectivism holds that individuals have free will, are
autonomous and independent: by using reason, they can determine their own
beliefs and values and thus control their own lives (“Man is a being of
self-made soul”). Objectivism rejects the view that an individual’s thoughts and
actions are the inevitable result of factors (e.g., heredity or environment)
beyond his control.
Ethical standards: Objectivism holds that ethics is objective and factual;
the standard of moral value is that which furthers the survival of man as a
rational being. Objectivism rejects the view that ethics is a matter of opinion,
that right and wrong are determined by social convention, ethnicity, personal
preference or religious commandment.
Morality: Objectivism holds that every individual is an end in himself—which
means that each individual should be selfish, should live by his own mind and
for his own happiness, neither sacrificing himself to others nor sacrificing
others to himself. Objectivism rejects the view that an individual’s moral worth
is determined by his altruistic service to society, the needy, the nation or
some deity.
Politics: Objectivism holds that capitalism is the only moral social system
and that the only proper purpose of government is the protection of an
individual’s right to this life, liberty, property and pursuit of happiness.
Objectivism rejects the collectivist view that government exists to further the
“common good,” the will of the majority or any particular group (e.g., the
working class); and, unlike libertarianism, it rejects the view that government
is evil by nature.
Ayn Rand’s positions on reality, knowledge, ethics and politics integrate
into Objectivism, which she called “a philosophy for living on earth.”